Tuesday, 31 March 2026

Frederick Elmes ASC / Eraserhead: Out of the Darkness

British Cinematographer

article here

Few debuts have been more disturbing than Eraserhead, the surreal body horror that announced the arrival of David Lynch. The project began as a short during the 24-year-old’s first year at the American Film Institute AFI in 1970 with Herbert Cardwell shooting early scenes.

“When it became clear that it was going to be a long-term project, Herb departed to get a real job, while I, still a starving student, took over,” explains Fredrick Elmes ASC.

Elmes, who joined AFI a year after Lynch, recalls first meeting the writer-director.  “David showed me some shots and I got a sense of it in gorgeous black and white 35mm.  I seemed a very simple story, a very simple character but it was also evident he was creating something out of the ordinary. There was nothing really controversial until the last shot of the baby and that piqued my interest completely.”

Lynch’s opaque narratives have come to be critically lauded and loved by audiences but as one of the first to encounter the auteur at his most raw, Elmes must share credit for shaping the look and tone of not only Eraserhead, but Blue Velvet and later, Wild at Heart.

“It was a matter of extracting,” he says. “David was not forthcoming with words or anything about story so it was up to me to figure out how to take the next step. Really, there was a great trust between us because [then] he didn't know me from anyone.”

The budding DP drew on clues he’d seen in a couple of Lynch’s paintings. “His sense of light and design and the graphic nature of it were really astounding.”

There no overall lighting plan. Elmes says, “We were lighting specific spots out of the darkness that had to be seen as the character moves from spot to this spot. I saw what was happening with just enough light on the wall for the character’s transition and that's all that David wanted. That became integrated into the style and really the feeling of the movie.”

As deliberately vague as he could be, Lynch could also be exacting. Recalls Elmes, “Early on Eraserhead, I remember going up to one of the tables as I was setting the shot and moving one of the props over to get a better composition. David said, ‘You know, we don't actually move the props.’ This was contrary to every other director I worked with.”

Eraserhead introduces Lynch’s signature transitions which seem to move from one reality into another dimension. “There’s a moment when Henry's alone in the room and about to have a dream. We cut to a bulb lighting up and then the camera starts to dolly and the next light bulb lights up and the next and the camera tilts up to reveal this stage, which you've never seen before with a character you've never met before. We appear to be in a different dimension; none of it's familiar.

“I chose to make those transitions in the most straightforward way possible. There was nothing tricky, there were no dissolves. It was really nothing out of the ordinary. We just treated it like the next scene in the movie. That simple approach became part of the film’s style.”

Eraserhead was supposed to be made in a few weeks but ended up taking five years as Lynch continually ran out of money but persisted in pursuing his vision. Only a handful of cast and crew, including lead actors Jack Nance and Catherine Coulson, stayed the course.

“It was a slow, methodical process. Most of the film was made by five or six people, including the actors who helped build the sets.”

Elmes continues, “AFI was extremely supportive. They gave us a load of equipment and lights. After they stopped giving us film stock they gave us the laboratory and a deferment on processing. They also leant David a little studio space where we could work and edit. It was wonderful, but at a certain point there were no more dollars.”

The AFI gave them short ends of negative from The Last Picture Show (Peter Bogdanovich’s black and white movie) that had just wrapped while Elmes would stop by Kodak on his way to work and pick up a roll of film “so that we had something to shoot that evening.”

Elmes even shot The Killing of a Chinese Bookie for John Cassavetes in 1975, just to pay the bills. When this happened, Eraserhead paused “partly because I took the crew with me.”

The almost non-existent budget had Elmes experimenting to create optical effects in-camera, “either running it backwards or upside down or doing some weird small thing.”

Members of the cast and crew kept the production afloat with donations. Lynch didn’t forget this generosity. At a diner with Elmes and Coulson he promised them a share of royalties with a contract written on a napkin. No-one expected the film even to be released, but Elmes confirms that Lynch’s handshake was honoured with an annual cheque.

“It became a very intimate relationship with David because it really was just a few of us shaping this story scene by scene. It did change, but it was our growth that changed it.”

Filming also took place in Elmes’ small West Hollywood apartment. “We had this exterior scene which required a number of bigger lights. I discovered I could climb on the apartment roof and tap into the power on the other side of the meter so we could plug in the bigger lights and wouldn't be charged electricity. It's a little dangerous now, when I think about it, but that's what we did to get it done.”


No comments:

Post a Comment