Tuesday, 17 November 2026

Camerimage: AI is threatening the DP’s craft

IBC

article here 

Films shot in the traditional way and often on film remain the artform’s high bar, but AI is gradually undermining the cinematographer’s position as the author of the image.
The opening film of the world’s leading cinematography festival set the tone for much of what followed. Artificial, Luca Guadagnino’s Open AI origins story starring Andrew Garfield as Sam Altman, is a challenge to the tech oligarchs who threaten to govern us all with unprecedented power. Meanwhile, AI is sweeping the film industry with reports from the front line suggesting it is actively undermining the director of photography’s role.
Guadagnino himself is in the ‘No’ camp. He declared after the screening that he wasn’t interested in using AI and that Artificial was shot on 35mm. The film’s cinematographer, Malik Hassan Sayeed, was more nuanced saying that AI was “a tool, like any other” while Darren Aronofsky, receiving an award for directing, repeated his own assertion that the technology was nothing to be afraid of.
“I don't know what hiding from it accomplishes,” Aronofksy said. “The reality is that even many people who passionately oppose AI are using ChatGPT or similar tools because they find them useful.”
The Caught Stealing director is prepping part of his next feature with AI and his company, Primordial Soup, has produced a number of AI-generated short films. While advocating experimentation and encouraging indie filmmakers to use AI to get their stories made, Aronofsky is not abandoning traditional techniques yet.
“I think these AI systems tend toward the average. It takes strong human intervention to push them somewhere genuinely original,” he said.
“Could AI read scripts and provide notes? Sure. Would I replace the people I trust to read scripts and give me feedback with an off-the-shelf model? Probably not. I trust those people because they understand my taste and my interests.”
“That's always been my approach with new technologies. Learn what they do well, identify their limitations, and then exploit those edges. That's where the most interesting creative possibilities usually emerge.”
There are however projects in production which are pushing AI to effectively create the show’s visual language without necessarily any input of the DOP.
“It's horrible,” said Bartosz Nalazek of an Amazon production he is currently shooting in Greece. “The creative adrenaline that normally comes from shaping images with light is gone. Sometimes it feels as if you've become an elevated camera operator rather than a cinematographer.”
According to Nalazek, the production (believed to be season 3 of the Biblical drama House of David) is using hybrid filmmaking alongside virtual production and conventional sets. It is the hybrid process that has him concerned.
“For the first time, it's possible to completely restyle an environment while preserving actors' performances,” he said. “Space, lighting, production design and many environmental elements can now be altered through prompting.”
Also disparagingly known as grey-box filming this has only been possible in the last few months with the release of the latest AI models. These can generate shots up to 30 seconds long, an advance on the previous 5-10 seconds.
Bitcoin, the latest film from director Doug Liman, has been made this way, apparently saving the production more than $100 million. ACME AI, the studio behind the film, has multiple grey-box projects in development.
As opposed to Virtual Production, where LED walls can be used to illuminate a scene, hybrid strips everything on-set back to bare essentials.
“Grey-box means shooting actors against a neutral environment,” explained Nalazek. “The model just needs enough contextual information to create parallax and spatial relationships.”
In fact, the AI performs best when they are fed with video that has minimal information. “In an ideal setup, you're almost working inside a neutral grey box with flat white light. As cinematographers, that's painful because we're used to creating atmosphere through lighting. But right now the model wants to see everything clearly before making its own decisions.”
In a demonstration of what is possible, delegates were screened a 120-second film titled Island, created using hybrid methodology by Artos Foundation, a group of filmmakers who want to understand AI in order to take back control.
The shoot itself wasn't dramatically different from a conventional production. They used professional cine cameras, lenses and focus pullers, worked with actors in costume and used simple props. These included a stick with a red marker attached that could later become a flaming torch. Props exist primarily as references that the model could interpret and transform.
The major difference was lighting with huge implications for the DP’s traditional authorship of the final image. “If enormous parts of the image are being relit and redesigned later, is the DOP still contributing to those decisions?” posed Nalazek. “Should I charge a consultation fee for giving them ideas? A career as a cinematographer is not sustainable that way.”
He challenged the industry to do more.
“This is urgent. We cannot simply wait and hope everything will work out in the end. If you  believe AI-generated imagery won't replace cinematographers think again. The reality is that this technology isn't going away. The way films are made is about to change.”
Fatherland takes home top prize
It  seemed almost perverse that films screened at Camerimage were shot traditionally on location (Visitation, The Mosquito Bowl) or with large budgets on giant sets (Project Hail Mary, Digger) or on celluloid. These included Wild Horse Nine (which won the festival’s Audience Award) and was shot in part on 16mm and Super 8; Club Kid, which takes a 35mm camera into New York’s club scene; and most defiantly of all, Werwulf the forthcoming gothic horror from Robert Eggers which pushed and pulled its 35mm colour negative through three grades to break the image to match the film’s extreme subject matter.
Fatherland, shot by Łukasz Żal in luxurious black and white won the festival’s main prize, the Golden Frog. The Polish DP’s previous work includes equally austere period drama The Zone of Interest, Ida and Cold War, the latter two directed by Paweł Pawlikowski and for which Żal was Oscar and Bafta nominated.
“The approach on Fatherland was the same as on our previous films, although perhaps there was even more discussion about philosophy and visual intent,” said Żal. “One of the concerns was making sure the film didn't become too beautiful. We were constantly asking ourselves how to avoid aestheticising the material. We wanted something closer to a documentary sensibility. If something felt overly refined, our reaction was often, ‘It's too good. Let's do something about it’.”
He added, “I remember people telling us after screenings that the film looked as though it had actually been shot in the 1950s and only recently discovered. That was perhaps one of the greatest compliments we could receive, because authenticity was always the goal.”
Project Hail Mary
Other films featured in the main competition included The Mosquito Bowl, La Bola Negra, Minotaur and Project Hail Mary, Behemoth!.
Cinematographer Greig Fraser said production process behind Project Hail Mary deserved to be studied by other filmmakers.
“There's often a push to reduce the costs associated with the creative process. Prep time is usually one of the first things that gets cut. On this film, however, the producers did the opposite. Very early on, they brought together the VFX supervisors, the production designer and myself to solve these problems collectively.
“By doing that, we found solutions that were actually more cost-effective. More importantly, we found better creative solutions.
This included building all of the spaceship’s environments in Unreal Engine before any physical construction began, so they could understand how all the spaces connected.”
He also discussed how to light interior and exterior views with ISS astronaut Don Pettit. “Space photography isn't limited to visible light. There’s infrared wavelengths, gamma rays and other parts of the electromagnetic spectrum beyond human vision. Nobody has travelled as far into space (as our characters) but everything we did had to be grounded in a plausible physical reality.”
Fresh take on the action genre
American DP Katelin Arizmendi had worked with Fraser as a second unit cinematographer on Dune and took those learnings into making Your Mother, Your Mother, Your Mother, a fresh take on the action movie starring Mahershala Ali as a John Wick-style Muslim hitman.
“Early in prep we met with stunt coordinator Adam Hart and I was very firm that I didn't want the action scenes to feel like they had been lifted from a different movie,” Arizmendi said. “At first he pushed back and asked how I expected to shot-list sequences when I wasn't designing the fight choreography myself. But my response was that the fights weren't the most important thing. We were making a studio film with action sequences, but not an action movie. The emotional journeys of the characters are what drive the story.”
She explained how they assigned emotional adjectives to each fight scene. For a sequence at a gas station the key words were precision and calmness and the camera had to reflect how controlled and methodical Latif (Ali) was.
“The second fight was about chaos so everything needed to feel unsettled and constantly in motion. The third fight takes place inside his home. That became about violation, family and remorse. We talked about using wider frames because we wanted audiences to feel the space around him and understand what was being threatened.”
The final confrontation became about revenge, warrior spirit and something almost mythic. “We joked that we were making a samurai film at that point.”
Volumetric video on a budget
German cinematographer and volumetric video specialist Martin Demmer took a workshop explaining how work with RGB and depth at a fraction of the budget of larger studios.
He has helped develop a software solution called Scanned Reality which he says can render volumetric clips within 10-20 minutes from a stage ringed by just a few camera sensors.
“The speed is incomparable to the bigger setups of the large studios,” he claimed. A simple 60-second recording equates to several Gigabyte of data but when ultra compressed is just 350MB – “ideal for VR, AR and Meta Quest deliverables or burning in human performance for later use in game engines,” he said.
Berlin-based Volucap, the studio behind The Matrix Resurrections, is currently working on the world’s leading mobile solution for ultra-high resolution volumetric video capture.

“That studio is on a different level,” Demmer said. “I don't even aim to beat them. I want to show you that there is a chance to work in this field without spending a hundred thousand dollars and to gain experience of such advanced techniques that normally goes on behind closed doors.”

Tuesday, 10 November 2026

The $22bn question: Can Roku remain neutral?

Streaming Media

article here  
The most consequential aspect of Fox's $22 billion acquisition may not be what it adds to Fox's streaming business, but what it changes about Roku.
For most of its existence, Roku occupied a unique position in the streaming ecosystem. The Switzerland of streaming if you will. Unlike Netflix, Disney+, Peacock or Paramount+, it was primarily a distributor rather than a content competitor. Its business depended on treating all streaming services equally and giving consumers access to as much content as possible. That neutrality helped Roku become one of the dominant connected TV operating systems in North America, reaching more than 100 million households globally.
Its acquisition alters that status. Fox already competes directly with Roku with free streamer Tubi (which reports over 110m global monthly active users) and with Fox One, a major owner of sports rights, it has one of the largest sellers of advertising inventory in television. The merger combines content ownership, advertising sales and distribution under one roof.
That vertical integration helps explain why regulators focused less on traditional market concentration and more on the possibility that Fox could use Roku's platform position - and the first party data of its huge viewing base -  to disadvantage rival content providers. The Department of Justice specifically investigated whether Fox might favour its own services or use Roku's scale to weaken competing FAST and subscription services. It concluded that substantial competitive harm was unlikely, but only after extracting commitments designed to preserve Roku's neutrality.
Those commitments include maintaining access to non-Fox content for at least three years, refraining from favouring Fox-owned services in search results and continuing to make Roku's data products available to third parties under existing commercial arrangements.
Fox's strategic rationale for the deal is built around gaining greater control over audience relationships, advertising and distribution. Roku's commercial success, by contrast, has depended on convincing every streaming service that it is an independent and trustworthy intermediary.
While not necessarily incompatible, those competing incentives could create tension. Fox CEO Lachlan Murdoch for instance suggested in a call with investors that content providers who are also distributors is the new norm. “We're partners right now with YouTube, YouTube TV and Comcast, and that doesn't change. We look forward to continuing healthy partnership with all our distribution partners.”
Fox has repeatedly pledged to preserve Roku as an open ecosystem, and from a business perspective it has strong reasons to do so. Roku's value lies in being the streaming industry's preferred storefront, not just Fox's. But the transaction raises broader questions about whether neutrality can survive once a content owner controls one of the industry's largest connected-TV platforms.
As the DOJ itself noted, Roku's platform value depends on the breadth of services available to consumers. Any perception that Fox was privileging its own products could weaken Roku's position with content partners and potentially encourage consumers to migrate to alternative Connected TV ecosystems such as Amazon Fire TV, Google TV or Samsung TV Plus.
The question is whether ownership gradually changes how content is surfaced, how advertising inventory is packaged, how audience data is monetised and how Fox's own services are integrated into the user experience.
Besides the eventual merging of the companies’ tech stacks Roku and Tubi will lead the leader of free streaming TV market “outpacing Pluto TV and Samsung TV Plus in user scale and catalogue breadth” according to Ampere Analysis.
Fox estimates that about a third of the combined viewers of Roku and Tubi overlap, which Ampere’s data corroborates (calculated at around 86m users).  That leaves a gap of well over 100m of users which Fox “has great potential to close especially considering the two services do in fact have different content offerings,” Ampere suggests.
There are implications for sports too. Currently Roku has next to no presence in the sports market, but Fox has made a centerpiece of sport for Fox One.
“With the additional global reach of Roku, there’s a potential opening for Fox to start looking more at global sports rights,” states Ampere. “Crucially, its combined footprint provides extensive reach to marketers across both linear and streaming audiences – a key attraction for ad buyers looking to navigate a fragmented viewing landscape.”
In that sense, the deal highlights a broader shift occurring across streaming. Fox's purchase of Roku follows the same logic behind Amazon's acquisition of MGM or Comcast's ownership of both NBCUniversal and Peacock: controlling content is valuable, but controlling how audiences discover, access and monetise that content may be even more valuable.

For Roku, that raises questions about what happens when an independent platform becomes part of a larger media conglomerate. Its future will depend on convincing content partners, advertisers and consumers that neutrality survives ownership by a company with substantial interests of its own.
how audiences discover, access and monetise that content may be even more valuable.
Some analysts are skeptical that this deal will generate value for Fox shareholders. As Doug Creutz of TD Cowen noted, “The history of content/platform mergers in media has generally not been kind.”


Wednesday, 4 November 2026

BBC AI lab's Alice Taylor: “A world away from slop”

IBC

article here

Alice Taylor, the head of BBC Studios new AI Creative Lab describes a “strong, cautious enthusiasm” among production teams for the initiative.

Alice Taylor has a straightforward view of what she does not want the BBC Studios AI Creative Lab to produce: more AI “slop”.

“Certainly from the creative community, I think fully generated, not very supervised is what we would call slop. And nobody’s into that game,” says Taylor, who joined BBC Studios at the end of last year to lead its newly established AI Creative Lab.

For Taylor, the distinction is between AI as a replacement for creative decision-making and AI as a set of tools that can support it. “It is technology that serves the creative process and serves the workflow,” she says. “Everything that we put out, if and where an element of AI is in that workflow, it’s going to be a portion of the pixels on the screen. Which is a very different world from slop that’s out on the internet.”

That approach is central to the lab, which was established to explore how rapidly developing AI technologies can be applied across BBC Studios’ global production operation. Taylor reports to Zai Bennett, CEO and Chief Creative Officer of BBC Studios Productions, and is responsible for developing the lab’s strategy, building its specialist team and working with production genres including Scripted, Unscripted, Audio, Kids & Family and Global Productions.

The lab is not intended to be a separate production unit that simply makes AI-generated programmes. Instead, Taylor describes its remit as working with creatives to understand AI and determine where it can genuinely help them.

“Creatives come first. They describe what they’re imagining,” she says. AI can help shorten the distance between that initial idea and a visual storytelling element, whether a pre-visualisation or a shot. “That can be really sped up, which means they can do more. They can, as we say, throw more spaghetti at the wall, try more things.”

Taylor joined BBC Studios after almost a decade at The Walt Disney Studios, where she was Director of Technology Innovation and Head of StudioLAB. There, she led a cross-functional group focused on storytelling technology, products and experiences, working with technology companies including Microsoft, Accenture, HPE and T-Mobile.

Her projects included ‘Remembering’, an interactive experience on Disney+, work bringing Walt Disney “back to life” for the Disney 100 Exhibition, and an immersive Secret Cinema production based around Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 2. Before Disney, she founded MakieLab, a company that combined digital avatars, 3D printing and traditional toy manufacturing to create customised dolls and action figures. MakieLab was acquired in 2016.

The combination of creative production and emerging technology is therefore familiar territory. At BBC Studios, however, the scale of the brief is different. AI is potentially relevant to almost every stage of production.

“At this point AI is such a broad term,” Taylor says. “There are tools that are AI-based that have already emerged for every single step of the production pipeline, whether it’s whiteboarding through to VFX, post and marketing, through to further down the content pipeline.”

The challenge for the lab is therefore not just identifying new technology. It is working out where it is useful, where it is mature enough to deploy and whether it improves the creative result.

“I’m looking at the existing workflow at every step of the way, because we have to preserve the creative intent,” Taylor says. “We have to not only preserve the creative intent, but maximise the creative intent.”

The lab is benchmarking tools as they emerge and assessing existing production software as AI capabilities are increasingly built into it. But Taylor says the process starts with the creator rather than the technology.

That principle also shapes the lab’s approach to AI-generated writing, directing and final-pixel imagery. Taylor is unequivocal that the human creative remains central.

“One hundred per cent. We are people first, creativity first, trust first,” she says. “We’re coming at this 100 per cent from our creative-led opportunity space.”

The lab’s small team is being built around that philosophy. Since January, Taylor has hired two people; Rish Dhir who’s a Creative Technologist with experience at Metaverse VR and Red Bull and Nathan Hubble, a filmmaker who founded automation studio Atta Bouy who’s the Program & Automation Manager. The ideal candidate, she says, combines technical expertise with an understanding of how television and content are actually made.

“I was looking for kind of creator-inventors,” she says. “Folks who have a film and television or creative background in some way, but also have technology expertise and hands-on expertise with AI.”

VFX, animation and film or television production are particularly relevant backgrounds, alongside an instinct for modernising established workflows.

The lab is also intended to operate as a bridge between production teams and the wider technology ecosystem. Taylor says BBC Studios is talking to UK-based research and development organisations, although she is not yet naming partners.

Her previous career gives her a wide network to draw on. During her time at Disney, she was responsible for relationships with technology companies and led StudioLAB’s innovation portfolio. She also spent five years running MakieLab between London and Los Angeles, developing a business around the emerging intersection of digital content, games, customisation and physical products.

She continues to track developments internationally, including in the US, Europe and China. Asked whether her relationships with major AI companies give her access to technologies before they are publicly released, Taylor declines to elaborate.

“I’ve signed too many NDAs to answer that question,” she says. “I think I would say we have great relationships and can stay on top of the absolute cutting edge of what’s going on.”

For BBC Studios’ production teams, the response to AI so far has been what Taylor describes as “strong, cautious enthusiasm”. The attraction is partly practical. Production companies are under pressure to deliver high-quality programmes within constrained budgets and schedules, while creators are looking for more time to develop ideas, research and storytelling.

“Our brilliant folks are always asking the question: how can I tell better stories with the budget that I have, in the time that I have?” Taylor says.

That enthusiasm is balanced by concern about audience trust. Taylor says creators want to experiment, but “they’re also hyper responsible”. The objective is to use the technology “correctly, carefully, without misleading the audience, without losing trust”.

That distinction becomes particularly important when considering the audience’s response to AI-generated material. Taylor acknowledges that there is a spectrum of opinion, including viewers who enjoy fully AI-generated video. But she sees a significant difference between that material and AI used as part of a professionally supervised production process.

The latter, she argues, is not entirely new. Machine learning and other forms of AI have already been used in areas such as animation and VFX for years. What is changing is the breadth and accessibility of the technology.

For now, the lab is focused less on predicting where AI will end up than on testing what it can do for creators today.  

“I don’t think AI will create new formats, but I think AI enables the creatives to have more ideas faster,” she says. “It will throw up ideas, if you ask it to, but it’ll be humans that create formats.”

Historically, she argues, creative ambition has been constrained by time and money. If technology can give creators greater freedom within those constraints, it may ultimately lead to new ideas and new forms of storytelling.

The first results from the lab’s work will take time to appear because television production operates on long cycles. Some BBC Studios programmes already contain AI elements, Taylor says, and work that began after she joined is expected to start appearing on screen within roughly a year, depending on the production.

For Taylor, that is the point of the lab: not to make AI the story, but to establish where it can make the creative process better.

“More is not necessarily better,” she says. “But better is better and we’ve got to focus on that."

Tuesday, 3 November 2026

What do regulators want from standards?

IEC E-tech

How do legislators use IEC Standards and conformity assessment? Ahead of the IEC General Meeting (GM) in Hamburg, we ask regulators around the world for their feedback.

article here

A key question which will be addressed at the IEC GM in Hamburg is how independent standardization and regulators can work effectively together. The relationship between regulation and standards is becoming increasingly important as technologies such as artificial intelligence (AI) connected products, software-defined systems and digital infrastructure evolve faster than traditional rulemaking processes.

Regulators need standards bodies to provide expert, up-to-date technical solutions. Standards organizations, on the other hand,  rely on regulatory feedback to identify emerging risks, safety issues and market needs. Stronger collaboration helps maintain consumer trust and supports innovation. It also reduces barriers to international trade and ensures global interoperability. It protects against fragmented national requirements and duplicated testing and regulatory uncertainty. This cross fertilization between regulation and standards allows products to reach markets more efficiently while meeting consistent safety, performance and public-interest objectives.

“Standards turn complexity into practical action,” says Pouline Terpager, Director of International Policy at Danish Standards. “They support compliance, safety, innovation and efficiency by providing recognized methods and a common language. But we also need standards that are faster to develop, less ambiguous and easier to use across sectors.”

Terpager along with senior executives at the US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) and Singapore’s Competition and Consumer Commission (CCS) share their views on how regulation and standardization complement each other and shape trust.

Eric Franca, Director for the Conformity Assessment Program (CAP) and Assistant Director at the Division of Standards and Conformity Assessment (DSCA) at the US FDA.

How do IEC Standards help the FDA in its work?

Consensus standards play an important role in supporting medical device premarket submissions. The FDA leverages these national and international standards through our recognition process to help streamline our premarket review and thus speed patient access to safe and effective medical devices. From the IEC 60601‑1 series of standards and more, the FDA is committed to helping develop regulatory-ready standards that we can recognize. We need manufacturers to  declare conformity to them in order to support FDA pre-market submissions and bring safe and effective medical devices to patients.

The Center for Devices and Radiological Health (CDRH) also modelled the Accreditation Scheme for Conformity Assessment (ASCA) Programme off international and national conformity assessment (CA) programmes, including the IEC CB Scheme operated by IECEE (the IEC System of Conformity Assessment Scheme for Electrotechnical Equipment and Components). Schemes like these help us to increase our confidence in the CA activities and can help streamline what we need to look at before a device can access the US market.

What would you like to see in future standards development?

FDA and CDRH support prioritizing the development of regulatory-ready standards, meaning that standards should strive to have clearly defined methodology that is easily reproducible across competent CA bodies. This includes clearly defined acceptance or pass/fail criteria and uniform expectations for reporting results from the testing. Ideally, that is a goal that can be achieved across standards development organizations and with relative speed in relation to the technology it is standardizing.

Having regulatory-ready standards may not only improve how standards use is conveyed to regulatory authorities, but it may also improve how CA bodies demonstrate their competencies in testing to standards covering these highly complex technologies. One of the strengths of the IEC is having the IECEE testing report form (TRF) working groups operate with the standards development process. This critical element helps ensure that the standards translate well to CA activities.

Do standards accelerate or put the brake on innovation? 

There are instances where the standards community has responded very quickly to a global need, such as the COVID pandemic which saw a speedy publication of standards to address global needs like ASTM F3502 Standard Specification for Barrier Face Coverings, first published in early 2021 or ISO 80601‑2‑90  for high flow nasal cannula which was published within about a year of the approval of the new work item proposal. However, there are cases where innovation moves quite rapidly and the development of standards, in particular regulatory-ready standards, takes a bit more time - which I would characterize as placing a controlled mechanism in place to measure for safety and provide harmonized approaches to market entry.

Look no further than AI. This is an area where the development and use of the technology is moving extremely quickly and standards development is moving at a more deliberate pace. This is understandable. It’s more important to take time to get the testing or methods in the standards to a point where consensus can be achieved than it is to publish something quickly that doesn’t serve the use of the technology.

At the same time, regulators are also interested in seeing how testing new, emerging technologies under competent pathways, in which we have confidence, can provide assurance for improving and protecting public health. Ultimately, having regulatory ready standards that have the necessary testing or methods built in, while keeping pace with evolving technology as quickly as possible, would be beneficial.

Pouline Terpager, Director of International Policy at Danish Standards

What would you like to see in future standards?

We need standards that are faster to develop, less ambiguous and easier to use across sectors. Online development tools and SMART, machine-readable standards can help companies integrate requirements directly into compliance systems and wider business frameworks. Digital tools, however, must preserve consensus and quality. Also, a deep cooperation between IEC and ISO is needed to address the challenges brought up by many new technologies such as Quantum, AI, etc.

How can the synergy between standards and regulation be achieved consistently and globally going forward?

Consistency requires a clear allocation of roles. Regulators should define public-interest objectives; standards organizations should develop voluntary technical solutions through transparent and inclusive processes that might support legislation. These roles should not be confused. The EU’s New Legislative Framework is based on this approach and has been a tremendous success and a model for regulators in other parts of the world. International standards used in this way lead to a pathway for easy trade across the globe, without unnecessary red tape.

The EU is about to revise the New Legislative Framework and the way it works with standards in support of legislation. I hope that the revision will continue its approach based on the use of  international standards, whenever relevant for public objectives to continue to support a well-integrated and safe European and global market.

What role can international standards play in supporting innovation while ensuring trust, safety and market access?

Innovation creates value when it can scale. International standards provide common terminology, interfaces, test methods and safety principles. They also play a role in lowering entry costs and opening markets. A Danish analysis found that companies buying standards subsequently achieved stronger growth than companies which didn’t: on average, they had 12% higher exports after one year and 8% higher revenue after four years.

Standards also build trust. In a Danish survey on ISO/IEC 27001, 84% said it helped with legal and compliance requirements, 87% gained a shared overview of risks and 71% reported more trusted relationships with external stakeholders.

IEC 60364 on low-voltage electrical installations is a concrete example of this. Its European adoption, HD 60364, is referenced in Danish rules, showing how an international foundation can support regional and national regulation.

Beatrice Wong, Director for the Product Safety, Weights and Measures Division, at the Competition and Consumer Commission (CCS) of Singapore   

How do you view the relationship between standards and regulatory objectives?

Laws and standards play different but complementary roles. Legislation establishes safety obligations, regulatory authority and consequences for non-compliance. Standards provide the technical benchmarks and test methods that support consistent implementation so that enterprises have greater certainty in their business practices and costs.

Legislative references to standards should be clear and kept up-to-date as regulatory and technical issues evolve. This can be achieved if regulators have a meaningful voice in standards development. They can contribute timely evidence from incidents and market surveillance. They can also raise implementation issues and emerging risks with the relevant technical committees. Standards developers, in turn, should give regulators access to appropriate technical expertise, helping standards to remain globally relevant and forward-looking.

Global consistency should mean common safety objectives and technical foundations, with justified, transparent and proportionate national adaptations where necessary. Standards should also remain responsive to technological change and real-world product experience, particularly as products increasingly combine electrical functions with software, connectivity and AI. Safety is assessed at the whole-product level and against a reasonably foreseeable use.

Do standards accelerate innovation or slow it down?

Well-designed standards can accelerate innovation by establishing clear safety principles and test methods. This gives innovators a clear understanding of the outcomes their products need to achieve, reducing uncertainty for product designers. It also builds consumer and regulatory confidence in emerging technologies and facilitates access to multiple markets.

However, standards can constrain innovation when they prescribe established designs too narrowly or are not updated quickly enough. Emerging products may combine functions or use operating principles that are not fully anticipated by existing standards. From a competition perspective, standards should also avoid unnecessarily favouring particular technologies or approaches. Where standards are sufficiently open and objective, businesses remain free to compete on how best to meet the required outcomes, which can in turn support innovation and the development of alternative solutions.

To remain enabling rather than restrictive, safety standards should focus on hazards, safety outcomes and reasonably foreseeable use. The standards development system should also provide practical routes for addressing genuinely novel products. IEC Publicly Available Specifications (PAS) can provide a faster route for addressing rapidly evolving technologies because they may be approved through a simpler process than a full international standard. A continuing challenge is securing timely participation from suitably qualified technical experts to keep standards responsive without compromising technical rigour.

How important is national flexibility for global standards?

A global standard delivers the greatest value when its core safety objectives and technical requirements are applied consistently across jurisdictions. Unnecessary national deviations can increase compliance costs, duplicate testing and reduce the benefits of international standardization.

At the same time, some national flexibility is necessary due to differences in local operating conditions, infrastructure and regulatory experience. These may include the voltage and frequency of the standard electricity supply, climate, national plug and socket systems, installation practices or risks identified from local incident and market surveillance experience.

Singapore therefore uses international standards as the technical foundation, supplemented where necessary by clearly stated local requirements. For example, Controlled Goods in Singapore may need to be assessed for operation at 230 alternating current volts (VAC) and 50 Hertz, to meet applicable tropical-condition testing. And they will also use appropriate plugs or fixed wiring arrangements in compliance with local requirements.

National adaptations should be risk-based, transparent and technically justified as well as limited to what is necessary. From a competition perspective, national adaptations should also avoid creating unnecessary barriers to market entry or disadvantaging particular suppliers or technologies without objective justification. This helps preserve the benefits of international standardization while ensuring that legitimate local regulatory needs are addressed.

Where a local issue is also relevant to other jurisdictions, there should be a mechanism to feed the evidence back into the international standards process so the global standard can evolve accordingly.

How do you and your team work with IEC Standards?

IEC Standards form an important part of Singapore’s consumer product safety framework. Under the Consumer Protection (Safety Requirements) Regulations, specified categories of household electrical and gas appliances and accessories are regulated as controlled goods. Before controlled goods can be supplied to consumers in Singapore, they must be tested to the specified safety standards, registered with the CCS Consumer Product Safety Office and carry a safety mark. Many are based on IEC standards, including IEC 60335‑2‑24 for refrigerators or IEC 60335‑2‑35 for instantaneous water heaters.

We adopt a risk-based CA approach. Depending on the product’s risk level, registration may require type testing supported by either a supplier’s declaration or independent certification. Singapore recognizes test reports issued under internationally recognized accreditation arrangements, including the IECEE CB Scheme, helping to streamline CA and reduce unnecessary repeat testing.  This approach reflects our view that international standards applied in the appropriate national context support both consumer safety and efficient market access.

 

Monday, 2 November 2026

BTS - Wild Horse Nine

IBC

Martin McDonagh writes specifically for places and characters that inspire him, and Easter Island could not simply be recreated elsewhere, DoP Ben Davis explains

article here

Isolated in the Pacific, 2,300 miles from the mainland, Rapa Nui provides an extraordinary setting for Martin McDonagh’s Wild Horse Nine. Its green hills, violent history and monumental moai statues establish a world that is both beautiful and unsettling, reflecting the film’s blend of political intrigue, dark comedy and emotional complexity.

The location itself was non-negotiable, explains cinematographer Ben Davis BSC.

“Martin wouldn't have made the film anywhere else. It was only ever going to be on Easter Island.”

Working with McDonagh for the fourth time after Seven Psychopaths; Three Billboards Outside Ebbing, Missouri; and The Banshees of Inisherin, Davis says the director typically develops a project privately before bringing collaborators into the process.

“I'm used to working on films where they’re still writing the script as you're making it but never with Martin. He has usually told me about the project that's in his head as a general outline but he’ll only send me the script once he's completely happy with it and that's exactly what we make.”

Wild Horse Nine is set in 1973, shortly before the CIA-backed coup which toppled Chilean president Salvador Allende. The story evolved considerably from an earlier version that was also set on Easter Island but featured different characters and a different historical period.

“This is far more political than anything he's made,” Davis suggests. “It was only after Martin went there and spent some time in Chile that he realised what he wanted to say. I guess there's a lot of anger in what we see in politics at the moment, so this story was a response to what's going on in the world since making Banshees.”

Davis himself had visited Easter Island for a week in 1999 giving him a head-start in imagining the script playing out.

“From the first outset I felt both Martin and I wanted it to have colour and contrast and we wanted you to feel this big juxtaposition between Santiago and Easter Island.”

To develop the look, he took several cameras on a location scout, including a stills camera loaded with Kodak Ektachrome, a Super 8 camera also loaded with Ektachrome, and a digital camera.

“It was the same process with Banshees [where Irish west coast island Inis Mór was a principal location for the fictional Inisherin]. When you go there, naturally there's a lot of weather and it can be very windswept with slate-grey seas and overcast.”

He says they wanted to contrast the island’s beauty with the melancholic mood of Chris, one of two bickering CIA protagonists (played by John Malkovich, the other by Sam Rockwell), holidaying among the moai.

“Chris is a man coming to the end of his life and trying to comes to terms with what he has done. There's a line of dialogue about a college student he has met on the island where he says ‘She's life and I’m leaving it’ which I think speaks to a part of all of us that becomes very aware of the beauty of the world that we’re leaving. So it was very important that the island felt like that, with big punches of colour.”

Another idea that Davis pitched to McDonagh was to evoke the 1970s strongly enough that audiences might imagine the film had been photographed in the period, “without making the imagery excessively nostalgic or reverential.”

To achieve this the production shot on a mix of film and digital. The principal camera was the ARRI Alexa 35, with select scenes captured on 16mm and Super 8mm film.

The opening sequence establishes this layered approach. Archival 16mm footage of crowds cheering Allende’s electoral victory in the Plaza de Armas de Santiago in 1970 bleed into the dramatised narrative shot at the same location on Super 8mm.

“It was very important we get that right. It’s always tricky to balance exteriors in bright sun to a darker interior, but here we also segue from grainy library footage into the Super 8 which is an integral element of the film.”

The Super 8 material is nominally shot by Chris as a home video accompanied by his narrated introspection. Davis also used a 16mm camera to capture dusk scenes and details of the island that he felt were important to the story (some of it tuned in post to resemble Super 8) while aerial photography is used to establish the island itself. Davis briefed a drone operator and pilot to film an “arsenal of shots” for coverage.

“If you shoot an island from land you could be anywhere but to show you’re on an island and how isolated it is, you kind of need to remove yourself photography from the ground.”

Although there were opportunities for elaborate camera movement, much of Wild Horse Nine unfolds through extended conversations, often between two characters in a car or sitting at a table.

“You could circle around them and do funky moves, but this isn't that sort of film. The cinematography has to serve the story. If you started to notice what the camera's doing, then I've failed in some way because you should really be listening to what they're saying.”

Davis and ‘A’ camera operator Des Whelan frequently worked with two cameras and shot multiple takes, allowing McDonagh and editor Mikkel E.G. Nielsen to explore different emotional registers in performance.

“The idea was to give editorial a wealth of coverage so that they had control over the rhythm of the film and options to cut these intense conversations with wider visual counterpoints.”

Davis chose vintage Super Baltar lenses for their distinctive rendering and gentle fall-off, favouring their imperfections over a more clinical image. He also carried Cooke lenses, switching to them particularly when characters were positioned towards the edges of the frame.

Achieving consistency across the acquisition formats required extensive preparation, not least because of the distance the production was from any post facility, let alone a lab.

He developed a LUT with Goldcrest colourist Adam Glasman, referencing the colour photography of William Eggleston, and in post worked on “isolating colours that you want to punch, like the red car, to sort of leap off the screen at you.

“Ektachrome really lends itself to colour so then we had to find a way of getting the digital to look like Ektachrome and it was a long process. It doesn't come naturally to get it that way.”

Davis elaborates, “I really do like shooting digitally but there are certain things that film does better. Particularly in the colours of day exterior where you're looking at these deep blues, these greens and this punchy red - film just does that right out the bat. You develop it, it comes back and you go ‘Wow! that looks great.’ To get the DI to look like that you have to work a little bit in post.”

Supported by Cinelab Film & Digital, dailies were sent to London where Glasman arranged remote grading sessions with the DP “just to tweak things. Generally we set up with a look we wanted and didn't do any messing around with it on set. The costumes and sets were all predetermined and tested.”

The Super 8 and 16mm rushes were only shipped to Cinelab at the end of ten weeks’ principal photography. “Fingers crossed, it was alright.”

Later Cinelab performed a Digital-Film-Digital (DFD) process, transferring the graded digital images onto 35mm film negative before scanning them back into the digital workflow. The transfer was made onto Kodak 50D stock.

Davis explains, “It just broke up the highlights in the digital footage and gave it more of the softer character we wanted. When you’re looking at hot sun on sea you get a lot of specular highlights which on film just works but on digital you can be left with hard hot lights, back lights or shiny faces. That’s a wonderful thing that film does that we had to try and emulate later.”

Much of the film’s budget went on the logistics of getting equipment to the island, including period cars. “We had to be very frugal with what we brought and that included a very small crew,” he says.

The production built two hotel rooms as an annex to an existing hotel on the island.  These accommodate substantial interior and exterior action, allowing the production to preserve the physical continuity and authenticity that Davis says McDonagh values.

“Everything with Martin has to be genuine. There could never be a combination of a plate shot on location with a set build. He writes specific to a location and to a specific cast.”

A national park representative and an archaeologist accompanied the crew, access to certain areas was restricted (some heads are also burial grounds), and camera equipment was kept away from protected sites.

Davis believes that, despite the irreverence of some characters’ dialogue, the film treats the island and its people with respect.

“The heads are sort of silent observers. They all share the same facial expression, like a slight grin, whatever they're looking at. We also have animals in Martin’s films – horses in thie case - which are innocent victims and also silent observers of characters that I don't think you're supposed to love.

“I think you're supposed to love and respect their friendship, which is really endearing, but they’ve both killed a lot of people. They've done some despicable things in their lives. So the whole island could be seen as silent character commenting on them in some way.”